Wondering how to teach your 1 year old no? How to tell your 1 year old no and have your 1 year old learn to obey? There are 4 phrases we've used with all 4 of our 1 year olds that really help! #parentingtips #parentingtoddlers #1yearold grace based parenting; gospel centered parenting

How to Teach a 1 Year Old “No” – Complete Guide to 1 Year Old Discipline

Today I’m going to outline a very effective plan for consistent 1 year old discipline for you to use with your toddler. From our experience of having 4 kids in 5 years, it’s never too early to start setting expectations and training your little ones. 1 year olds understand WAY more than we realize.

It might seem silly because those 1 year olds are so darn cute… with all their wobbling around and giggling at endless games of peekaboo. But teaching your 1 year old, “no” and learning how to discipline a 1 year old will set the stage for more obedient toddlers and preschoolers.

So let’s dive in!

A quick overview of what this article covers:

  • What discipline even means for a 1 year old
  • What discipline DOESN’T mean
  • How to deal with screaming
  • 4 key phrases to start using with your 1 year old
  • How to teach them “no,” and not make it a joke
  • What we do for timeout
  • Introducing obedience in a simple way
  • Saying yes a lot!!

This post has a LOT of ideas, so feel free to pin it/ save it for later if you want to come back and reference it!

p.s. I’m working on putting together a short, self-paced toddler parenting course. It’ll be comprised of short, downloadable audio-files that you can listen to at your own pace. It’s full of practical tips you can use with your toddlers in every day life. Sign up below if you want access to the launch discount codes.

1 year old discipline tips
1 year old behave disicpline baby

Wait, what is “discipline” at this age anyway!?

The word discipline sounds so old fashioned and serious. And these 1 year olds are so darn cute…what with all their peekaboo and toddling around.

The word discipline has latin roots meaning “instruction, knowledge,” so in English, we use discipline in a variety of ways…

1 year old discipline

When I’m talking about discipline for your 1 year old, I’m primarily talking about teaching and training that little cutie pie

You are probably going to be the one who:

  • holds their hands as they learn to walk
  • teaches them how to say “please” in sign language
  • shows them what the letter A looks like
  • hears them sing Twinkle twinkle little star for the first time
  • shows them how to stir the brownie batter and not splatter it all over
  • teaches them how to make a cookie cutter shape in the playdough and stack the blocks up.

AND you can teach them not to scream in your face when they don’t get their way. (Eventually.)

That teaching process – the one for the screaming (or other defiant behavior) is what’s called discipline.

At the age of 1, discipline is setting the foundation for HABITS + OBEDIENCE under a loving authority.

Honestly, at the age of 1, it’s boils down to behavior modification and teaching them about who is “in charge” in the home.

During their preschool years, if you are a Christian and want a gospel-centered home, you can start to introduce the gospel to the conversations surrounding obedience. But the good news about Jesus Christ won’t be super effective with your tantruming 14 month old πŸ™‚

Side note: the BEST book for parents of 1 and 2 year olds

1 year old discipline terrible twos
Skip your next 2 lattes and treat yourself to this book. It’s almost always less than $10 and will pay off great dividends in the long run.

Honestly, this is the most practical, down to earth book I’ve ever read for parents of toddlers. And if your little one is only 9 months old, you will be well served by reading this BEFORE you have a 12-18 month old.

The “twos” can start anytime around age 1 1/2. John Rosemond does an AMAZING job of articulating what is ACTUALLY going on for 1-2 year olds, and how parents can help their little tots through the transition from baby to big kid. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE read this book!!!

Back to this post.

You are the parent, you are in charge.

We advocate for a parent-led home. Parents being in charge of the home doesn’t mean the child doesn’t get to be in charge of some things.

The parent in charge can delegate many things to the little tot, giving him/ her many things to be in charge over. We say “yes” to a LOT of things for our small children. (John Rosemond explains this REALLY well in that book I told you you need to buy immediately mentioned.)

  • You want to wear polka dots and stripes? Fine.
  • Mismatched socks? Go for it!
  • No coat in the rain? Sure! You’ll be wet but if it doesn’t bother you, it doesn’t bother me.
  • 13 Books and 10 stuffed animals in bed? Seems uncomfortable to me, but why not?!
  • Take out all the pans in the cabinet? Noisy, but okay!
  • Scream “no!!” and hit me when you’re frustrated? NOPE.

You can be in charge without being a dictator AND while still allowing your child a lot of freedom and decision making. In fact, children feel MORE confident when they know their parents are the ones in charge.

Okay. Now that we’re on the same page about what 1 year old discipline means, let’s get to the nitty gritty practical stuff…

1 year old discipline

Phrase #1 for 1 year old discipline: “That’s a No.”

This simple phrase is literally the biggest secret to teaching your 1 year old “no.” Using “that’s a no,” instead of just “no” is really effective for 1 year old discipline!

I don’t remember where I first heard this phrase, but it stuck with me. I do remember that I started saying it to our first child when she was about 8 or 9 months old. And, I felt kind of awkward saying the whole phrase, “That’s a no” instead of just “no.”

As we got used to it, we liked it better than ‘no,’ because it is more specific. It first comes in handy when your newly crawling almost-one-year-old starts exploring. We like to make the house relatively exploration friendly and then teach a few specific things/ places are off limits.

Cords are the first thing all our kids have gone for. They’re just so dangly and enticing. Especially laptop cords! My husband and I both have laptops that we leave in various places around the house.

Being home with them all day, I need/ want to be able to leave my computer out and know they’re not going to a.) pull it on top of themselves b.) break the expensive computer c.) break the expensive charger d.) somehow get electrocuted from the plug.

Enter – “That’s a no.”

How exactly to teach your 1 year old “no” with this phrase

This might not need explanation, but, we’re pretty deliberate with how we teach this, so, in the spirit of oversharing, I thought I would give you a step by step for how using this phrase to teach your 1 year old “no” might look.

  1. Baby crawls towards charger.
  2. As soon as she touches it or reaches for it, I clap loudly (to get her attention/ break her focus) and say firmly “Emma, that’s a no” while pointing to the forbidden fruit item.
  3. I often repeat again with the item inserted, “The charger is a no.”
  4. Then I bring her away from it and distract her with something else. I carry her away facing away from me and put her down on the ground across the room. (Note about this below*)

As I’m first introducing this phrase, I would let her go for it a few times so I could instill ‘that’s a no’ and really get them to hear it a lot.

(Just don’t make it a game where you’re chasing them toward the charger for fun! It’s hard not to turn it into a game because they’re so dang cute. More about that in a minute…)

When baby first starts crawling, you are just teaching him or her what this phrase means and how to listen to that firm mommy or daddy tone in your voice.

You don’t have to apply ‘that’s a no’ to every single off-limits thing right away. We kind of informally picked cords as the first thing we taught ‘that’s a no’ with because they are everywhere, at our house and other people’s houses, and they’re semi-dangerous.

With other things we didn’t want them playing with, we’d just move them out of reach, or say “that’s a no” one time and then move them away or whatever.

It’s so exhausting to try to monitor every single off limits thing at this age, so we focused on one thing (cords) to teach this concept of listening and obeying the phrase “that’s a no.”

How to discipline a one year old baby with “that’s a no”

*The specifics of Disciplining a 1 year old and enforcing “that’s a no” will vary based on your parenting styles, and your child’s personality.

We have 3 children who are relatively compliant (and one who is NOT). I clapped loudly by them and used my firm mommy voice to say, “THAT’S A NO.” (not yelling – just a firm tone) Then, I moved them away from the off limits situation and put them on the ground across the room, and they promptly burst into tears.

Or, they might not cry, but that momentary “separation” basically did the trick.

That process of saying no firmly, and moving them away from me was enough to cause them “pain…” They now associate the phrase “that’s a no,” with displeasing you and realize that they don’t want to do that.

After 10 seconds, I always scoop the child up, smile and say, “Mommy loves you. That’s a no. No cords. Listen and obey mommy. ” Then we go play or do something else/ I distract them.

We also had a less compliant child who, in the same scenario, smiled and turned around and went right back towards the same object, smiling at me the whole time. Daring me to mean what I said. At the ripe old age of 14 months! (Perhaps you can relate!?)

Some people call this a strong willed child πŸ™‚ The amount of determination “strong willed children” have, of course, varies from child to child.

For any repeated, clear disobedience like that, we always flicked the top of the child’s hand while saying, “that’s a no.” He would look surprised, sometimes shed a tear, and we’d all move on.

Here’s why we were okay with this: the key to discipline is CLEAR BOUNDARIES + EXPLANATION + PAIN + LOVE.

You can read our whole parent-led home philosophy in detail, but the “pain” point is what people have trouble figuring out. And it’s incredibly unpopular to say! (I hope I don’t get kicked off the internet for writing this!)

The thing is – it’s not actually pain. I am not talking about abusing or hitting your 1 year old. So everyone please calm down…

Also, just try it on yourself. Flick the top of your own hand and feel how “painful” it is. (Ahem: basically no pain at all). But that tiny amount of surprising, momentary discomfort communicates to the child what you mean when you say, “that’s a no.”

So much better than the pain of, say, pulling a lamp on top of your head or getting electrocuted from sticking a fork in the outlet… ya know!?

You can also try putting them in a crib or pack n play. We did these short “time outs” in a crib with the lights on and door open, and the baby wasn’t confused about whether or not it was nap-time. More details about this in the next section.

A compliant 1 year old will learn this VERY quickly. A strong-willed 1 year old will take more time. But if you are consistent, they will learn! I promise.

Don’t discipline a 1 year old for being childish!

They’re 1, for goodness sake. Do not make every single thing in your home a “no.”

Your one year old is going to empty all your drawers and cabinets, climb the stairs, explore and touch and eat everything… And if your older toddler leaves water out, your younger toddler will dump it all on the ground πŸ™‚

teaching a one year old no

Baby Proofing + Proactive “Discipline”

Yes… I know we could move the laptop. But we want them to begin the process of learning to obey before we’re in a parking lot and I need my child to immediately “STOP!” on command.

The laptop is a great situation for teaching “no” because it’s not life or death.

We do prevent/ avoid some situations

We don’t mess around with teaching “no” about our steep and dangerous basement stairs; we just keep the door closed. The bathroom doors stay shut so the 1 year old doesn’t fall head first in a toilet. And we don’t expect our toddling 13 month old to stay next to us in the parking lot. We just hold her.

Also, we do move a lot of things out of reach because it’s not worth dealing with every single little thing being off limits.

For example, I don’t put sharp knives in the toddler-accessible silverware holder in the dishwasher.

And I don’t keep any decorations on any end tables during the stage of a 9 month old learning to pull up because they just pull everything off the end tables and throw it all onto the floor.

We keep the bathroom doors closed, and the glass cups up high.

I don’t want to be saying, “that’s a no” all day long.

(Sorry-not-sorry to drone on about that Terrible Twos book, but Rosemond has a really helpful chapter that explains the 1 year old’s nature of exploring and how simply making your home 1-year-old friendly will save you SO much grief with your curious tot.)

Dealing with frustrated screaming

Ahhh those 14 month olds… they have so many opinions and so few words. Which leads to… lots of screaming!

The big thing with the screaming is – discern the motive of the screaming/ crying:

  1. Is the child frustrated or disappointed?
  2. Are they attacking you and being defiant?

Much of the year between 1.5 and 3 is spent on the child developing a higher tolerance for frustration. This begets patience, a lovely quality in any child! And it can be taught. Here are some proactive ways to help your tot exercise his or her currently non-existence patience-muscle.

If your child is frustrated, try one of these things…

1. Give him a chance to figure it out.

Offer a few options for what you think he is trying to say. “Water?” “Snack?” “I can’t understand you.” If you’re not sure, just change the subject. Remain calm, and take them to a different room and play.

Try to avoid excessive, coddling speech. “Oh mommy doesn’t know what you want! Oh no, I’m so sorry. I don’t understand. Perhaps you’d like this or that or this or that.” πŸ™‚ No need to bend over backwards to appease your confused little one. They often don’t even know what they want!

If you ever DO figure out what the child was saying, you could practice it with them…

“OHHHH, a drink of water!” When you want a drink, you can come get a cup like this and show it to me! Then I’ll know you want water. Come on, I’ll show you how. Come get a cup in this drawer.”

Kids love role play! So any time you can make a role play/ pretend game out of a skill they need to practice, that’s a great preventative toddler strategy.

Or you can say “waaaa-terrr” really slowly. Encourage them to try. Show them the sign language for it. Then, talk about/ sign water a lot in books and at meals and whatnot until they learn to say the word.

2. Distract/ redirect the 1 year old with something else.

Just move on! If they’re frustrated because they can’t communicate what they’re trying to tell you, just take them somewhere else and find a new activity. Continue to remain calm and avoid coddling.

They’re so fickle. Most 1 year olds will be happily distracted by something shiny and different.

3. Let them cry and move on.

We all cry when we’re frustrated and small children cry when they don’t get their way. (Heck, so do I sometimes!) It’s part of life.

Your 1 year old will likely get over the disappointment relatively quickly if you don’t make a big deal about it.

Our youngest child loved to eat the markers that his big siblings leave laying around… I usually take the marker away and calmly say something like, “You can’t eat the marker. Sorry.”

He’ll burst into tears while I take it away and throw it in the trash, then I’ll go back, pick him up and say, “I know that’s disappointing. Let’s go play choo-choos.”

He’s sometimes over it before I even finish my sentence.

Around 18 months ish, this strategy won’t work as well because you’ll offer the choo-choo or distraction of choice and he’ll throw it on the ground still in a rage that he can’t eat the marker. 

At that point, I usually gently set the child down and walk away. Or I say something like, “When you’re done crying, we can play something else,” as I walk away.

A very basic rule of 1 year old discipline is:

Reward what you want repeated.

And I don’t mean reward like a sticker. I mean coddling & attention. If you give lots of attention and fuss to tantrums, tantrums will definitely continue.

Don’t coddle fits at all. Especially once they’ve become defiant. Speaking of which…

Defiant Screaming & Time Out Tips for Toddlers

Whether they’re increasingly frustrated or not ticked that getting their way, or just screaming defiantly at you in the first place…

Often, I just walk away and it dissolves. This not-so-revolutionary parenting strategy falls under “reward what you want repeated.”

But, as your 1 year old gets closer to age 2, he/she will develop a unique ability to melt into a solid heap of screaming child. It’s totally normal. You are not a bad parent! They are just toddlers. And this is what toddlers do.

If walking away doesn’t work, here’s our approach to time out.

We remain calm but firm, carry them to a room or crib or chair, and say, “No fits. You may not throw a fit when you don’t get your way. Time out.”

OR: “No fits in the kitchen/ family room. If you want to scream because you’re mad, you’ll have to stay in your room.” Then walk away.

I know it’s so hard to remain calm! My kids have revealed a deep-seated rage in me that I didn’t know existed before the first child turned 17 months old! Haha! They can be so frustrating. Take deep breaths. Pray for patience. Be the grownup.

(You won’t be perfect!! It’s okay. Give yourself some grace too.)

How to Get a 1 Year Old to Stay in Time Out

In order for this to work, your mentality is key: There is no “battle.” I’m not arguing or fighting you. Because you (the screaming 2 year old) are not in charge of anything in this situation. You have to have a parent-led mental state in order for this to work. Set limits, be firm but patient & don’t give up!

If your child is under 2 or 2.5, time out is SHORT.

For a young toddler, time out is really about exercising your authority and showing them how time out works. I suggest placing them on a chair with your calm, firm tone: “No, no screaming. Time out.” Then, step back. 3 seconds later, step towards them and say, “All done. Mommy’s in charge. No screaming.”

That’s it – move on! No long lectures or drawn out battles with an irrational 22 month old! Likely, they’ll calm down quickly. Hug & reassure them: “I love you. I forgive you. You may not throw a fit when you don’t get your way.” OR “you can’t scream at mommy even when you’re really frustrated.”

As they get older, you can lengthen time out gradually. In that book you have surely bought by now, Rosemond has some good ideas for older toddlers who insist on head banging, kicking furniture, etc.

Phrase #2 for 1 year old discipline: “shake shake shake”

Another thing we noticed about the word “no” is that you can teach your baby “no” about the same time they start to shake their head back and forth (like you shake your head, “no”).

The problem with this is, the head shake is super cute! And they love to play the shake-your-head game.

BUT if you associate the shake-your-head game with the word, “no,” then when you say, “that’s a no,” they’ll cutely shake their head no! Like it’s a game. πŸ™‚

What we’ve done to counteract this is use the phrase “SHAKE SHAKE SHAKE” for the head shaking game and stick to “that’s a no” (in a firm voice) for teaching “no.”

However you go about teaching this, the point is to teach your child to respond to you when you’re serious, and make sure they know you’re not playing a game when you use “that’s a no.” 

Joking is fun!

Yes! We joke with our kids all the time! Just not about the word “no” at 10 months old, right when they’re first learning what “no” means.

Here’s an example of the joking we try to avoid:

Chasing them as they crawl toward the laptop charger or outlet or fan or whatever because everyone is smiling and giggling as you say “no no little sugar plum…”

This makes it really hard to make your “no” mean NO for real down the line. If your 1 year old doesn’t listen to no, pay attention to whether you accidentally use the word as a joke sometimes.

We do the fun crawling chasing game all the time still; just not surrounding the word “no” while teaching what is off limits.

We do joke about “no” as the kids get older!

Our 2-6 year olds love asking something outrageous and hearing me laugh and say, “No way, JosΓ©!”

As a child grows to age 2 or so, s/he can understand the teasing more. We’ll tease: “Don’t have any fun at Grandma’s house while we’re gone!!” And our kids will laugh and respond, “We will! we will!”

Or we’ll say, “You better not eat your veggies!!” And they’ll laugh and say, “I’m going to!!” (How’s that for awesome reverse psychology? haha!)

The point is… once the boundaries are clear, and they can tell what “no” means and that you are in charge and you mean it when you say, “no,” then you can joke freely.

BUT for the months where you are actually trying to teach your one year old, “no,” don’t mix up the word with any sort of game! It’ll make it all easier πŸ™‚

Phrase #3 for 1 year old discipline: “Yes Mommy.”

In conjunction with teaching “that’s a no,” we also teach “yes mommy.”

Sometime around 8-12 months, your little one starts very cutely and deliberately nodding their head yes.

It’s harder for them physically than shaking their head no. Once baby can nod, I say “yes” a lot and nod with them so that they learn the nod means yes.

Sometimes I’ll play a game of going back and forth between nodding and shaking for the baby to imitate me:

  • Baby shakes, I shake and say, “shake shake shake.”
  • Then I nod, and say, “Yes, yes, yes.”
  • And baby copies the nod, giggling.
  • Sometimes we mix a peekaboo in here too! It’s all fun and for the point of associating head shakes with “shake shake shake,” and head nods with “yes.”

It doesn’t take long for baby to associate the head nod with “yes.”

Once they understand it means yes, we add the head nod/ “yes” to the whole ‘that’s a no’ situation.

How to teach “yes mommy!”

I’ll say, “that’s a no… no cords. Say yes mommy.” Then I’ll nod with baby and say “yes mommy,” (as if the baby is responding.)

The idea is that they nod to symbolize they understand that you are telling them something. Introducing “yes mommy” super early on will pay off BIG TIME in the “terrific 2s.”

The baby may not actually nod at the right time for a long time… that’s okay! Just do it anyway. They’ll catch on.

At first, it’s all just instilling the habit. The true understanding comes a bit later.

Our second daughter was around 13 months when she started nodding almost every time we said, “Say yes mommy.”

That doesn’t mean she obeyed perfectly… obviously! It’s just our way of instilling the habit of her responding when we tell her something. This way, when she turns 2 and we’re going on a walk, I can say, “you need to stay on the sidewalk and not go into the street” and she says “ok mom” and I know she gets it.

Around 1.5-2 years old, the “yes mommy” will likely go from a head nod to words. It was later for my 3rd son…. all his words came a bit later than the first two girls.

Sometime around 2, they develop the ability to even say “Yes, mommy” thru gritted teeth.

Once the child has built the habit of acknowledging when they hear you and understand you, it’s easier to identify and distinguish between when they’re going against what you’ve told them, and when they just don’t know any better.

Phrase #4 for 1 year old discipline: “Listen and Obey”

This is another one that felt awkward at first. I don’t know if the word obey is old fashioned or feels culturally unacceptable or what, but I used to find myself slightly self-conscious using it in front of people.

7 years and 4 kids later, I’m basically over that. “Listen and obey” rolls off my tongue any time, any place.

The idea behind “listen AND OBEY” (as opposed to just “listen to me”) is that your child can listen and choose not to obey.

Going back to our parking lot example, if your tiny 2 year old wanna-be-dictator listens to you and hears you say “hold my hand please,” but disobeys by running the opposite direction, well, that could end badly. So, obedience is a key part of the “listen and obey.”

How to introduce and teach “listen and obey” to a 1 year old

“Listen and obey” is easiest to teach when you can help them obey. You’re not expecting obedience, really. You’re just teaching the concept of what “listen and obey” means.

Example 1 : Teaching Clean Up Your Toys

You can say “it’s clean up time, put the toys in the basket,” then you basically put all the toys away and guide the 12 month old’s hands to drop the toy they’re holding in the basket.

While helping them do all the work you say, “Good listening and obeying mommy. Clean up time! Great job!”

In this way, you are teaching the concept of ‘listen and obey’ as a positive thing. I’m all about the positive!!

Example 2: Throwing Food

We worked on “listen and obey” with our second child around 13 months old. By that age, she totally understood we didn’t want her purposefully throwing food on the floor.

During a meal, when I handed her the plate of cut up food, I’d say “Emma, there is no throwing food on the floor on purpose. Say yes mommy.” (I’d nod my head and answer myself, yes mommy.) She eventually mimicked my nodding for “yes mommy”.

Then if I was nearby and noticed she seemed to be thinking about throwing food, I’d reach over to help her put it back on the plate and say, “Good listening and obeying, Emma!! Yes, your food stays on the plate. Not on the floor.”

The older child usually gets excited too and claps and says “Yay, Emma!” πŸ™‚

As your one year old gets more words, he or she will be able to say the word ‘obey.’ At some point, they got old enough (around 2 years old) to where we would say “you need to listen and _____,” and each child would fill in the blank “obey.”

It’s kind of synonymous with a ‘yes mommy.’ Some sort of acknowledgement of their understanding.

I still use it all the time with my big 3 at ages 2.5, 4.5, and 6! Often more of a reminder. When I can see one of them teetering on the edge of disobedience, I just quietly remind her/him, “Listen and….” and much of the time, they’ll say “obey” and comply.

(Notice I didn’t say they comply all of the time.)

There are no perfectly behaved toddlers.

Hear me on this, friends.

Our kids aren’t perfect.

Perfection is not the goal. Good behavior all the time isn’t the goal either. Eventually, there will be lots of opportunities to preach the gospel to your kids in their moments of sin. To show them their behavior reveals their heart and that what who they really need is Jesus. There will be many opportunities for you to apologize and show them Mommy needs Jesus too.

But when your child is 1, focus on teaching your 1 year old to obey. It will set the stage for all the other, more important stuff as they get older.

My 13 month old still threw food on purpose. Less often, but it still happened.

The 2 year old sometimes unplugs my laptop or splashes water out of the tub like a hurricane, even though she knows better.

When our oldest was 2, if I sent her to time out, she’d yell “noooo” as she ran to her room… one final act of defiance. Haha!

Isn’t that how grownups are too, though? God graciously enables us to get increasingly better at attitudes and behaviors… but we’re never perfect. I am not perfectly patient with my kids, but I’m more patient than I was a year ago. I do not put others first 100% of the time, but I’m less selfish in my parenting than I was 4 years ago. (Some of the time…)

Grace.

Let’s give our kids grace, whether they’re 1, 7, or 29. Grace doesn’t mean permissiveness…. it means we teach them obedience, then love them no matter what!

Consistency, explanation, discipline, love, patience and grace.

Ok. I’m curious & want to know if anyone already uses any of these phrases with their kids… or are you going to try them? Do you have other phrases that your kids respond well to? Start/ join the conversation in the comments below!

This raising small children thing is not for the faint of heart. They are persistent and stubborn little firecrackers – full of energy and so so needy. Let’s come along side each other and help a momma (or pops) out!

RELATED POSTS:

How to Deal With the Terrible Terrific Twos!

Don’t call my 2 year old terrible!

1 year old obedience

17 thoughts on “How to Teach a 1 Year Old “No” – Complete Guide to 1 Year Old Discipline”

  1. Gotta do what works for you!! Glad you found some helpful things… starting the training process early will really help when the next little one comes along. Haha somewhere on this blog I have a post about 2 under 2 πŸ˜‰ We had 2 under 2 three times! LOL! Good luck!

  2. Dealing with an incredibly strong willed almost 14mo old daughter right now, who is my first, and man oh man is every day a doozy it seems like. I loved the phrase “that’s a no”! Definitely going to have to try that one. Not a fan of the phrase “listen and obey” however, I’m thinking “listen and follow” will work well for us, like following the leader or maybe even incorporate it with “mama says” so it’s like Simon Says. I realize she is not familiar with these games yet, but will be in the future and has an 11yo sister and will have a younger sibling come December. Thanks for the advice, I’m going to need it (and some patience, deep breaths right?! 🀣 )

  3. so glad this was helpful!! We’ve noticed phrases with the word “choice” are confusing for 1-2 year olds… the whole “make a better choice.” “Was that a good choice?” type phrasing seems to confuse them. I’d stick to short & sweet. “No. That’s a no. Here, do this instead.” πŸ™‚ welcome to the blog!!

  4. I know it’s an old post, but thank you! Oh my goodness. I have been a live in nanny, elementary school teacher, babysitter etc., all ages for 10+ years. But I now have a one year old of my own and WOW, she is giving us a run for our money. But I’m realizing that she will already do absolutely ANYTHING for attention, so your positive behavior suggestions are such a great idea. Like she LOVES pretending (or not pretending) to put forbidden things in her mouth so that I come running. Why haven’t I thought to play a game of chase with her just for fun? 🀦

    Or I love the “yes, mommy” and nodding suggestion because she already turns her head away when I want her to stop something and she doesn’t want to listen.

    We already do, “listen and obey” or “make a different choice” (even though I know she doesn’t understand, I always say this and then suggest something else to her when she is going for forbidden cords/outlets – also what we’ve been working on).

    I would add that sometimes when my little one just gets in screaming about everything fits (not even not getting her way, just screaming to scream), that 10 minutes of mommy play time does wonders. Sometimes I’ve been too focused on getting all the things done, and forget that she just needs some mom face time (not eating or getting dressed or whatever but me down in her world playing) to fill her little bucket. After that, she’ll usually quiet down and happily entertain herself for a good stretch.

    Anyways, excited to read more on your blog and will definitely check that book out!

  5. Thank you so much for talking about this. I have been reading everything I can to get advice on how to discipline my strong willed one year old. Your advice is so practical and loving. We have been struggling to find a good balance between making sure he doesn’t turn into a brat but also not crushing his spirit. This might just work for us!

  6. Briawna, yes! He actually became a Christian later in his adult life – so he’s been giving out parenting advice for decades, as a psychologist/ family counselor. He wrote several books over the past 30 years. Then, in his book “Parenting by the Book,” he shares the story of his conversion and how he realizes the basic, practical parenting advice that his grandma would have agreed with was actually mostly Biblical and he didn’t even know it. Haha! So, yes, he is a Christian. Although his writing is not directed at Christians at all. He takes a gentle-but-firm tone, and is very funny!

  7. Oh my goodness, Ariel!! I’m so glad you found this! And thank you – your words are kind. We are no “experts” by any means… but 4 one year olds + lots of prayer has given us some insight. πŸ™‚ Also we love John Rosemond’s book. His book, “Making the twos terrific” is a great read!

  8. Hi Renee!

    This has been the most helpful post on disciplining a young toddler in a godly way that I have read so far! I have a 15 month old son who has started throwing tantrums, and I was desperate to find a way to discipline him in a way he’d understand. I will try out your phrases and time out ideas, praying they work!

  9. Oh, Alura!! What a blessing to hear from you. God gave Alexander to YOU to be his mom, and that wasn’t a mistake!! Keep seeking the Lord – he has ALL wisdom for parenting. And in the meantime, I’m glad some of these blog posts were also helpful πŸ™‚

  10. Alura Franklin

    I just had my son Alexander 14 months ago, and I feel like I blinked and all this time has just flown by SO fast, and the older he keeps getting the more and more I realize how totally unprepared I actually am. ??
    I had a pretty unstructured/tough upbringing (to say the least) so it’s like now I know for sure how I DON’T want to parent, but figuring out how I DO, in a way that is the best for my son, is proving to be alot more complicated.
    I just found your blog and it has seriously answered so many questions that I have been praying the Lord would give me some guidance on!
    I just wanted to let you know that you sharing your journey and parenting knowledge is truly appreciated, especially by this Momma! ?

  11. oh I’m so glad to hear that Devin!! No discipline method is foolproof but hopefully this helps you guys in a practical way!! It seems to me that homes with obedient children are happier πŸ™‚ both the parents and kids. So this is a great foundation!

  12. THANK YOU! For this post. We’ve been really struggling with our one year old. We’re 100% sure she understands β€œno” but she doesn’t react to it well. So helpful in our parenting. Thank you!

  13. Oops!! I got one of the titles wrong. I did like “Loving the Little Years,” but it’s not the one I was thinking of. “Loving the Little Years” was a fun, easy, encouraging read. But my ALL TIME FAVORITE motherhood book thus far is “Treasuring Christ When Your Hands are Full.” πŸ™‚ Sorry for the mixup!

  14. Mariel Schmitt

    Hi Renee! I love this and am bookmarking it to share with Paul and for us to use in the very near future. My Emma turns 9 months next week and I know that all of this is just around the corner for us. I love your intentional parenting and wish I could be near you to get together and soak in your wisdom!! But for that reason I’m thankful your sharing your ideas on your blog πŸ˜‰ Do you have any books you recommend that have influenced your parenting values?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *